Make a Payment

Make a one-time payment online Go paperless, save time and save some trees

Give us a call:

Call 800.477.1660 to make a payment or if you have questions regarding your bill.

Mail your payments to:

Indiana Farmers Insurance, P.O. Box 856, Indianapolis, IN 46206

Overnight your payments to:

Indiana Farmers Insurance, 10 W. 106th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46290

Easy Way To Pay

Don’t want to worry about remembering to pay your insurance?
Consider having payments automatically withdrawn from your bank account ... no fees attached!
If you’d like to request a pay plan change or have questions about your bill, contact your agent or call us at 800.477.1660.

Payment FAQ

  • Are there any fees associated with paying online?

    Paying by ACH/eCheck will not incur a fee. Only credit card payments will incur a convenience fee added by our 3rd party payment processor.

  • Why is there a convenience fee when I pay by credit card?

    Our 3rd party payment processor requires a convenience fee when paying your bill by credit card. To avoid paying this fee, we also accept ACH/eCheck payments from your bank account.

  • If I don’t want to pay the convenience fee, can I still make a credit card payment?

    No. The fee is set by our 3rd party payment processor and cannot be excluded from your credit card payment. Paying by ACH/eCheck will not incur a fee.

  • How will the convenience fee appear on my credit card statement?

    Your insurance payment and the convenience fee will appear as a single charge on your credit card statement.

  • I would like to make my payment via my checking account. Is that an option?

    Yes. When you log in to make your payment choose the echeck option and this will be one-time payment from your checking account.

  • I recently processed my insurance payment online through my bank. Could you let me know how long it typically takes for the payment to reach you?

    Payments made this way are often sent as paper checks, which means they travel through the mail and might take some time to arrive. For a quicker and more efficient payment method, we recommend using our Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) option.

  • How can I pay automatically?

    You can pay automatically by using a checking or savings account.  To sign up, either contact your agent or log in to your account and select Recurring Payments. The system will offer you the option to add the policies listed within your account. Click on Add and follow the prompts to set up your policy. Recurring payments are currently only offered on a monthly payment plan.

  • Does creating a wallet in my online account automatically schedule my insurance payments for me?

    While a wallet securely stores your payment details, it doesn't handle scheduling. You'll need to take an extra step to set up your payment schedule.

  • If I schedule a payment in my online account, will it automatically schedule my next payment for me?

    Each scheduled payment in your online account is a secure, standalone transaction. No additional automatic payment scheduling will occur.

  • Where can I find my online payment number?

    Your online payment number can be found on your invoice. If your invoice is not available please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Eastern Monday through Friday. A representative can supply you with your online payment number or take your payment over the phone.

  • Can I split my payment between two different payment types?

    Yes. Please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Eastern Monday through Friday.

  • How do I change my billing method?

    Please contact your agent to change your billing method and to learn about all of our pay plans.

  • When will I receive my bill?

    Your bill is sent 24 days in advance of the effective date or your billing due date.

  • Why did I receive a Final Notice of Cancellation/Expiration? I have paid all invoices received.

    You may have only paid the invoice from one of your policy terms. If you feel there has been an error, please contact us at 800.477.1660.

  • Do you offer a good student discount?

    Yes. To receive the discount, the student must be getting at least a B average and be at least 16 years old. Please provide a copy of your student's report card to your local agent.